What Happens If Your Rental Car Is Reported Stolen?

what happens if your rental car is reported stolen

You’re cruising down the road in a sleek rental car, enjoying your vacation when suddenly, flashing lights appear in your rearview mirror. You pull over, confused, only to be informed by the police that the car you’re driving has been reported stolen. Panic sets in as you realize the rental car has a stolen plate. What do you do? This guide will help you understand the situation and provide clear steps on what to do if your rental car is reported stolen.

Understanding the Situation

Imagine you’re driving your rental car and suddenly, you’re pulled over by the police. They inform you that the vehicle you’re driving has been reported stolen. This can be a terrifying experience, especially if you have no idea how this could have happened. The police might detain you, conduct a thorough investigation, and even arrest you until things are sorted out.

There are several reasons why a rental car might be reported stolen:

  1. Miscommunication: Sometimes, car rental companies mistakenly report vehicles as stolen due to administrative errors or miscommunication.

  2. Stolen License Plates: The vehicle you rented might have been fitted with stolen plates before or after you picked it up.

  3. Failure to Update Records: If the rental company fails to update their records promptly, a car might be reported stolen if it appears to be overdue.

What Should You Do When This Happens?

If you find yourself in this situation, remain calm and take the following steps:

  1. Cooperate with Law Enforcement: Provide all necessary information, including your rental agreement, identification, and any documentation from the rental car company.

  2. Contact the Rental Company: Immediately inform the rental car company about the situation. They should be able to verify your rental and clarify any misunderstandings.

  3. Gather Evidence: Take note of all relevant details, such as the names of the officers, police report number, and any communications with the rental company.

  4. Seek Legal Assistance: Contact a lawyer who can help you navigate the legal implications and protect your rights.

Who is Responsible?

Determining responsibility in this situation can be complex. Generally, rental car companies are responsible for ensuring that the vehicles they rent out are legally compliant and not falsely reported as stolen. However, there are a few key points to consider:

Rental Company Negligence

If the rental company failed to update their records or rented out a car with a license plate that was reported stolen, they could be held liable for any inconvenience or damages you suffer. Proving negligence involves demonstrating that the rental company did not take reasonable steps to ensure the accuracy of their records and the legality of the vehicles they rent out.

Your Responsibilities

As a renter, you are responsible for adhering to the terms of the rental agreement and ensuring that you have all necessary documentation while using the rental car. However, you cannot be held responsible for administrative errors or the rental company’s negligence.

How to Prove Rental Company Negligence

To prove that the rental company was negligent, you will need to gather evidence that shows they failed to fulfill their responsibilities. Here are some steps you can take:

  1. Request Documentation: Ask the rental company for all documentation related to your rental, including maintenance records, vehicle history, and any communication about the reported theft.

  2. Collect Witness Statements: If there were any witnesses to your interaction with the rental company or the police, obtain their statements.

  3. Hire an Attorney: An experienced attorney can help you gather evidence, navigate the legal process, and build a strong case against the rental company.

Can You Sue a Rental Company?

Yes, you can sue a rental company if they rent you a car with a license plate that is reported stolen, leading to your wrongful arrest or other damages. Here’s when and how you can take legal action:

When Can You Sue?

You can sue the rental company if you can prove that their negligence directly caused your wrongful arrest or any other damages. This includes situations where:

  • The rental company failed to update their records.

  • The rental company rented out a car with a reported stolen license plate.

  • You suffered damages (such as legal fees, missed work, or emotional distress) as a result.

How Can You Sue?

To sue the rental company, follow these steps:

  1. Consult an Attorney: Speak with an attorney who specializes in personal injury or consumer protection law. They can advise you on the strength of your case and guide you through the legal process.

  2. File a Claim: Your attorney will help you file a claim against the rental company, outlining the damages you suffered and the evidence of their negligence.

  3. Negotiate a Settlement: In many cases, the rental company may offer a settlement to avoid going to court. Your attorney can negotiate on your behalf to ensure you receive fair compensation.

  4. Go to Court: If a settlement cannot be reached, your case may go to court. Your attorney will represent you, presenting evidence and arguments to prove the rental company’s negligence and the impact on you.

Impact of Wrongful Arrests

Being wrongfully arrested due to a stolen rental car can have severe impacts:

  1. Emotional Distress: The experience can be traumatic, leading to stress, anxiety, and other emotional issues.

  2. Reputational Damage: An arrest, even if wrongful, can harm your reputation personally and professionally.

  3. Financial Loss: Legal fees, lost wages, and other related costs can accumulate.

  4. Legal Consequences: Although eventually cleared, the arrest can lead to a temporary criminal record or other legal complications.

Damages Caused by Wrongful Arrests

If you’ve been wrongfully arrested, you may be entitled to various types of damages:

  1. Compensatory Damages: Covering financial losses, such as legal fees and lost income.

  2. Emotional Distress Damages: Compensating for the mental anguish suffered.

  3. Punitive Damages: In some cases, the court may award punitive damages to punish the rental company for gross negligence.


To avoid finding yourself in such a predicament, consider these preventive measures:

  1. Inspect the Vehicle: Before leaving the rental lot, check the license plate and ensure it matches the information in your rental agreement.

  2. Verify with the Company: Confirm that the vehicle’s records are up-to-date and there are no outstanding issues.

  3. Keep Documentation: Always have your rental agreement and any communication with the rental company handy.

  4. Regular Communication: If you extend your rental period, inform the rental company and get written confirmation.

How an Attorney Can Help You If Your Rental Car Is Reported Stolen

Dealing with the legal complexities when your rental car is reported stolen can be overwhelming. An experienced attorney can provide invaluable assistance to ensure your rights are protected and to guide you through the process. Here’s how an attorney can help you in such a case:

  1. Immediate Legal Advice and Guidance: When informed that your rental car has been reported stolen, an attorney can provide immediate legal advice and guidance, helping you understand your rights and next steps. They will review your rental agreement and any related documents to assess the situation.

  2. Interacting with Law Enforcement: An attorney can represent you during interactions with law enforcement, ensuring your rights are protected and all necessary documentation is provided. This helps prevent any potential legal missteps and clarifies your position to the authorities.

  3. Communicating with the Rental Company: Your attorney can communicate with the rental company on your behalf to resolve the issue quickly. They will document all interactions to ensure clear and accurate records for future reference.

  4. Proving Rental Company Negligence: To establish rental company negligence, an attorney will gather and present relevant evidence, such as rental agreements and police reports. They may also work with experts to support your case.

  5. Filing a Lawsuit: If necessary, an attorney will guide you through the process of filing a lawsuit against the rental company for negligence. They will handle all aspects of litigation, from drafting the complaint to representing you in court.

  6. Seeking Compensation for Damages: An attorney can help you seek compensation for damages resulting from wrongful arrest, including emotional distress and financial losses. They will negotiate with the rental car insurance providers to secure fair compensation.

  7. Navigating Insurance Claims: Insurance claims involving stolen rental cars can be complex, but an attorney can assist in filing accurate claims and resolving disputes with insurers. They ensure that you receive the coverage and compensation you’re entitled to.

  8. Preventing Future Issues: An attorney can provide advice on how to avoid similar problems in the future, such as thoroughly inspecting rental vehicles and understanding rental agreements. This proactive guidance helps protect your interests in future rental transactions.

what happens if your rental car is reported stolen

Renting a car should be a hassle-free experience, but complications like driving a vehicle with a reported stolen plate can turn your trip into a nightmare. Knowing your rights and responsibilities, understanding who is at fault, and being prepared to take legal action are crucial. If you find yourself in this unfortunate situation, seeking legal guidance can help you navigate the complexities and protect your interests.

For those in Nevada, facing such challenges, it’s essential to reach out to a local law firm experienced in handling cases involving rental vehicle disputes and wrongful arrests. They can provide the necessary legal support to ensure you receive the justice and compensation you deserve.

If you need further assistance or legal advice, please don’t hesitate to contact BLG. Our experienced attorneys are here to help you through every step of the process and ensure your rights are protected.

Contact us today for a free consultation.

Related Posts

Free Case Evaluation

The evaluation is FREE! You do not have to pay anything to have an attorney evaluate your case.